Sep 09

Many of my friends, colleagues, and family members have heard me rant about pity on many occasions. I am very proud of a recent seminar paper I am preparing for future presentation and publication (hopefully) that is titled “Why We Want to ‘Piss On Pity, or How The Ideology of Pity Is a Social Harm to People with Disabilities.” Surely, this blog will serve as a way to test drive many of my ideas about pity, as I try to sharpen them and work them out more fully. One of the main challenges raised every time I mention pity as a harm is the idea that there is something very positive that is closely related to and sometimes confused with pity. This “something” is sometimes called compassion or empathy or sympathy.

While I agree that this something is sometimes linked to pity in our thoughts somehow, I want to argue that this something goes so far beyond mere pity that it becomes its opposite. For the sake of this essay, I will call this something empathy.

While I am not going to take the time to completely lay out my argument for why pity is a harm, let’s start by saying that pity depends on the existence of a harmful power relation and serves as a way of preserving that power relation. For pity to exist, there must be a power inequality between the pitier and the pitiful. Someone must be better off than someone else and look down upon them from a perch of privilege. Pity preserves this set of pre-conditions because it does not acknowledge or work to change this power relation. In fact, pity treats this power relation as inevitable and natural. Responding to someone’s suffering with an act of pity obscures the fact that the root causes of their suffering could be changed. For example, let us say that someone responded with pity to a person with a mobility disability who could not access a restaurant because of a staircase. That able bodied person may express their pity with words of sorrow at the chair user’s horrid predicament at not being able to walk up the stairs. Perhaps, the able bodied person may offer to get a take out order for the chair user. However, these responses do not at all respond to the fact that the chair user could enter the restaurant if it was ramped. Once you make the move to thinking about the problem in this way, you move away from a response of pity and toward a response of justice. A ramped doorway is not an act of pity, but an act that equalizes people’s power status and contributes to considerations of justice.

However, just as an unequal power relation is a pre-condition for the existence of pity, it seems to me that empathy is a pre-condition to the existence of justice. The “golden rule” or the ability to place yourself in the situation of the suffering other in a genuine way (aka empathy) dismantles this power relation. When we are able to authentically imagine ourselves in the situation of the person who is suffering, we recognize that mere pity is harmful and that we must address the power relation itself that has created this suffering.

While talking to a friend who also has dwarfism a few days ago, she told me a story about the first time she meant someone that was homeless and had dwarfism. She was struck by their suffering, gave them a hug, and bought them lunch. The fact that she hugged this man speaks to me that this was an act of empathy and not mere pity. That is, she treated him as a respected friend rather than an other she was looking down upon. Without any prompting, she explained her actions as motivated by a sense that “that could have been me…” She recognized that the injustices in our society create a system where folks with disabilities like dwarfism (and every other kind of difference that would be characterized as disabling) face huge challenges of bigotry that severely limit their flourishing. With these words of “that could have been me…” she recognized that it was a matter of chance that she was born into a family that had the disposition and the means to not turn her over to the state for a life of institutionalization. The chance of her circumstances allowed her to join Little People of America and gain access to a network of support and eventually get a college degree so that she would not face the same suffering of this man on the street. My friend recognized that it was an accident of fate that positioned her to help this man in the way that she could and that this was a matter of injustice. This friend has developed a perceptive empathy for these kinds of situations and these experiences have moved her to become involved in the disability movement and pursue a law degree so she can address these matters of injustice head on. I think her desire to fight for and with the most marginalized folks with disabilities all comes back to her ability to say “that could have been me…”

  • prescription drugs from canada
  • flu treatments
  • online alcoholism treatment
  • best arthritis drug
  • over the counter hypertension medicine
  • senna constipation
  • new obesity drug
  • how to treat acne scars
  • l carnitine
  • list all vitamins
  • dosage for amoxicillin
  • diabetes order
  • cialis 20 mg discoun
  • canadian pharmacies
  • medical irritable bowel
  • anxiety depression
  • women insomnia
  • presciption free pharmacies online
  • treatment for erectile dysfunction diabetes
  • arthritis medications
  • buy zovirax
  • buy zanaflex
  • how to get generic cialis
  • gout medicines
  • buy xenical
  • pain control long term care
  • flu symptom treating
  • breast augmentation information
  • online prescription drugs
  • buy viagra soft
  • pain meds on line
  • buy cymbalta
  • consumer diet pill
  • benefit health woman
  • buy discount cialis
  • aldactone medication
  • online pharmacy ratings
  • ultram drugs
  • treatment of stroke
  • does alli work
  • new psoriasis treatment
  • hypnotherapy for weight loss
  • buy cla
  • insomnia depression
  • arthritis medicine
  • discount drug prescription
  • stress relief products
  • list of pain medications
  • medicin depression buy
  • weight loss food
  • fat loss diets
  • pet treats available
  • buy ambien
  • norvasc mg
  • aids and hiv treatment
  • increase womens sex drive
  • fast fat loss
  • prescription pain medications
  • mexican pharmacy online
  • on line drugs
  • pain medication for arthritis
  • buy viagra online get prescription
  • hepatitis c treatments
  • lean muscle mass
  • about viagra
  • bacterial infection remedies
  • accutane dosage
  • herpes drug
  • buy levitra no prescription
  • alcoholism treatment program
  • drugs for bipolar disorder
  • prescription pain patches
  • condoms buy
  • levitra fast delivery
  • buy generic drugs
  • congestive heart failure information
  • prescriptions for back pain
  • increasing erection
  • cholesterol reducing medicines
  • cheap bentyl
  • viagra effects
  • healthy dog food recipe
  • lexapro sleep
  • cat's health problems
  • dog medicine
  • kinds of muscle relaxants
  • what causes high cholesterol
  • anxiety paxil
  • delivery tramadol
  • discount nutritional vitamins
  • stomach pains and gas constipation
  • buying accutane
  • order drugs online
  • help for sleeping problems
  • preventing hair loss in women
  • viagra usa
  • online medication
  • purchase meds without prescription
  • preventing and controlling high cholesterol
  • prednisone interactions
  • order pravachol
  • pregnancy hair loss
  • discount generic viagra
  • tramadol 100 mg
  • asthma attack treatment
  • lipitor product
  • white spots on face
  • how to sperm more
  • relafen effectiveness
  • all natural vitamins
  • where to buy viagra on line
  • high calcium in the blood
  • hairball problems cat
  • drugs online
  • infertility treatment
  • vitamins store
  • consumer diet pill
  • prescription pain medicines
  • discount depression medications
  • how to cure insomnia
  • drug doxepin
  • increase womens sex drive
  • malaria treatment
  • order premarin
  • nolvadex buy
  • sleep problems
  • price for tramadol
  • heart failure medicine
  • acyclovir medicine
  • cheap phentermine without a prescription
  • drugs for pulmonary hypertension
  • acai tablets
  • weight loss meds on line
  • natural stop smoking
  • osteoporosis natural therapy
  • asthma medications
  • buy cheap soma
  • jelly viagras
  • generic kamagra
  • increase women sex drive
  • ambien dosages
  • natural back pain relief
  • buy generic viagra cheap
  • vitamin d and bone health
  • online pharmacies no prescriptions
  • buy viagra online australia
  • celexa withdrawal
  • depression pills
  • migraine headache treatment
  • stroke prevention programs
  • claritin online
  • home teeth whitening products
  • lexapro and depression
  • stop vomiting remedies
  • uk drug prices
  • how to get teeth white
  • natural pain killer
  • natural pet products
  • right side heart failure
  • clonidine dosage
  • arthritis care
  • phentermine 30 mg
  • tips to stop smoking
  • azithromycin 250mg
  • canadian lipitor
  • cheap celadrin
  • knee osteoporosis
  • buy lotrisone cream
  • cialis free
  • diet pill prices
  • increasing muscle mass
  • thyroid pill pet
  • viagra in australia
  • hiv treatment
  • online allegra
  • type 2 diabetes treatment
  • tooth whitening dentist
  • treatment for dementia
  • ear infection treatments
  • smoke stop
  • building your body
  • tramadol cheap price
  • drug free hair loss treatment
  • natural muscle and joint health
  • new medication anxiety buy
  • eczema vs psoriasis
  • coupon claritin
  • price nexium
  • over the counter weight loss products
  • drugs used for hypertension
  • cure acne
  • buy orlistat on line
  • removing dark spots from face
  • drug lipitor
  • online diet drugs
  • gain mass muscle
  • weight loss workouts
  • high blood pressure natural cures
  • cipro sale
  • chronic asthma treatment